Essentia Hospitals Come to an Agreement with Nurses

What’s taking Allina Health so long?

By Barbara Brady

Barb Brady
Barb Brady

MNA Communications Specialist

While MNA nurses in Duluth and Superior were working to reach a tentative agreement with Essentia Health on a new three-year contract this week, MNA nurses in the Twin Cities were preparing for a second strike against Allina Health.

Why is this a tale of two or four cities? There’s no reason Allina can’t follow Essentia’s lead and negotiate a contract that benefits the nurses and their employer.  Nurses really do put the care in healthcare.  They provide the value for the hospital.  Often, they are the first and last faces a patient sees when they’re admitted and discharged.

There are many similarities in the two sets of negotiations. Both started out with management proposing unreasonable concessions on health insurance and other key issues.  Essentia proposed a long list of unacceptable concessions, including major changes to time off benefits, overtime payments, staffing plan development, and nurses’ health insurance plans.  Nurses stood strong with their own list of proposals based on member input that, among other things, would improve safe staffing and workplace safety.

Over the months of negotiations, the parties reached tentative agreements on several key issues, including the creation of a workplace violence prevention committee that includes nurses and goes beyond the minimum requirements in the new law.

“Our team was united and had the support of the membership,” said Bargaining Unit Co-Chair Steve Strand. “Essentia kept insisting on concessions and we kept saying “no” while finding some areas we could agree on.”

Essentia nurses went to the public with their concerns about the corporation’s refusal to negotiate fairly, starting with members appearing before the Duluth City Council to seek support. Nurses also marched on the boss; posted billboards saying, “Has Essentia lost the care in healthcare? Ask an MNA nurse”; and held an informational picket attended by more than 600 nurses and supporters.

The message got through: Essentia apparently saw that the public supports nurses and that MNA members were standing strong. Essentia agreed to a new contract on August 31 that retains one of the nurses’ contract health plans and prevent Essentia from diminishing that plans’ benefits.  Nurses agreed to eliminate one of their two plans in exchange for a long list of improvements to make up for any losses they might incur with health insurance changes.  Improvements to the contract include:

  • Nurses will retain their protection from any diminishment in benefits
  • Measures to improve staffing by allowing nurses to permanently add to their FTEs beyond what is current allowed to ensure  higher numbers of nurses caring for patients
  • A $300 bonus upon ratification
  • An additional $300 bonus in July 2017
  • Substantial increases to each level of the existing annual longevity bonus
  • Increases to all shift differentials
  • An increase to the weekend bonus
  • Bonuses for nurses moving to the remaining health insurance plan; and for nurses already on that plan

“The negotiating team believes this agreement makes major improvements to our contract that benefit nurses and our patients,” Strand said. “Our advice to Allina nurses and all others in negotiations: stand strong in solidarity. It can work.”

Essentia nurses will vote on the tentative agreement on  Sept. 8. The MNA negotiating committee is recommending members vote in favor of it.  Allina is still demanding draconian concessions from nurses. It’s time Allina follows Essentia’s example and agree to a fair contract so everyone can focus on what’s important: caring for patients.



  1. I strongly believe that the MNA has done a really, really bad job of communicating the issues the Allina nurses are upset about to the public, AND to other MNA nurses. When I talk to fellow MNA nurses and ask WHY it’s come to this they either don’t know and don’t want to get involved, or they don’t know but want to picket anyway, or are able to offer some information about the proposed changes to health insurance. The friends and people I speak with who are not involved in health care in the Twin Cities don’t know what to think…if Allina is offering health insurance that’s good enough for their other 30,000 employees why isn’t it good enough for the nurses?, they ask. I don’t know what to say because I haven’t seen a detailed and understandable analysis of what the changes would mean for an “average” RN and her/his family. I’ve written to Mark Zdechlik at MPR asking him to give details in his coverage of the strike. When the nurses at Allina talk about their safety and the staffing levels, which never gets more than a mention in a sentence, what are they talking about? Details! The public is not going to get behind the nurses in this strike unless they can easily understand the issues and how the nurses, and, more importantly, their PATIENTS, are being negatively affected! This can’t possibly just be about health insurance! I hear rumors about Allina being a toxic workplace, about older nurses’ lives being made so difficult they leave. Is this true? I hear that the staffing levels can be unmanageable. What ARE they? I know the MNA thinks the coverage has been good. It hasn’t. And that, I think, is how we’ve arrived at this point. You need to educate the public in ways they can understand and that lead to empathy for the hardworking nurses at Allina so they can get behind them…perhaps in much the way the nurses at Essentia did.

  2. True! I did hear from a nurse that it was REALLY about staffing and staffing patterns but haven’t picked up on that in the media. That’s the issue the public will get behind. Get on it MNA!

  3. MNA is an absolute joke. I have been an employee with Allina Health for over 16 years and have walked the picket line twice. I have since changed my mind on the support MNA has provided. The public including myself, has in fact picked up on what this is really about; the NNU taking control of what they want.

Comments are closed.